Justice Samuel Alito said Thursday night that Congress has the power to cut off the Supreme Court’s money, warning that lawmakers can “turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening,” according to The Hill. He used the point to argue that the courts’ independence has to be protected.

He spoke on November 12 at the Federalist Society’s annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner, to a crowd of more than 1,000 conservative lawyers, The Hill and The Daily Beast reported.


What Alito said


Alito described the judiciary as the least powerful of the three branches and said it is vulnerable to Congress and the executive, The Hill reported. If that independence is eliminated, he said, “the Constitution as adopted in 1789 will no longer be the same.”

He did not only defend the courts. He also criticized lower-court judges who, in recent years, issued what he called “unjustified” orders blocking presidents’ policies. Judges “make mistakes,” he said, and in some instances “have gone far astray in abuse of their powers,” according to The Hill.

Alito did not mention the midterms or the change of power in Congress, according to both The Hill and The Daily Beast.


Why it lands now


The dinner came a week after Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate, The Hill noted, and it said Democrats have in the past considered using Congress’s power over spending as leverage against the court’s conservative majority. The Daily Beast pointed to a letter in which Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, announcing his bid for speaker, told colleagues Congress must “clean up the mess at the Supreme Court.” No Democratic plan to cut the court’s budget has been announced.

For what Democrats could actually do with their new majorities, from ethics rules to term limits to adding seats, see our explainer on whether Democrats can expand the Supreme Court.


Can Congress really defund the Supreme Court?


Partly. The Constitution gives Congress control of federal money: no money can be drawn from the Treasury except through appropriations made by law, under Article I, Section 9, according to the National Archives transcript. The Supreme Court’s budget is one of those appropriations, passed by Congress like any other.

There is one firm limit. Article III says federal judges, including the justices, hold office during good behavior and that their pay cannot be reduced while they serve, the same transcript shows. So Congress cannot cut the justices’ salaries. What it controls is everything around them, such as clerks’ pay and the upkeep of the building, as The Daily Beast noted.


Has the court run out of money before?


Yes, briefly, though not because Congress targeted it. During the 2025 government shutdown, the court said it expected to run out of funding on October 18, 2025, Yahoo News reported. It closed its building to the public but kept doing its core work, including hearing arguments, issuing orders and opinions and processing filings.

The court also depends on Congress for its security money. Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett made a rare visit to Capitol Hill to ask for the judiciary’s budget and more security funding, citing rising threats, The Hill reported.


What we don’t know


Whether any member of the new Democratic majorities will propose cutting or conditioning the court’s funding. None has been announced.
Whether Alito’s remarks were aimed at a specific proposal. He did not name one, according to the reports.
Alito’s own plans. Questions about whether he or Justice Clarence Thomas might retire are covered in our piece on whether Alito and Thomas will retire before Democrats take the Senate.