According to Italian law, a sequestered ship must be maintained and cannot be left to rust or sink. If and when sanctions against Melnichenko are lifted, he will have to pay back those costs to retrieve his vessel. “It will eventually cost him less to buy a new yacht than to pay back all we have spent,” Dipazza said. “And where does that leave us? We could be paying for this monstrosity for years.”
Melnichenko, a banker and industrialist whose fortune is estimated at around $20 billion, challenged the seizure of the yacht in the summer of 2022, arguing that the vessel was not directly owned by him, but instead a company called Valla Sails through a trust set up by his wife. The case was heard by a court in Rome in 2022 and eventually reached the Court of Justice of the European Union, which ruled in 2025 that Italy has the right to keep it sequestered – and with it, the obligation to maintain it.
Sailing Yacht A is not the only Russian yacht costing Italians money. In the Tuscan port of Marina di Carrara, the six-deck, 465-foot superyacht Scheherazade is docked behind high walls to keep it both safe and hidden from curious onlookers. While it is reportedly licensed to Rosneft executive Eduard Khudainatov, Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny credibly claimed it actually belongs to Russian President Vladimir Putin.
On August 28 of this year, it left the port heading north towards the Italian Rivieria, according to transponder signals recorded by Vessel Finder, heavily flanked by Italian security forces. It returned after ten hours of what a spokesperson for the Italian Sea Group, whose dock it is moored at, said were technical tests as part of its maintenance.
The superyacht, worth $700 million, has twin helipads among its many amenities and a swimming pool that converts to a dance floor, according to Superyacht Times.
The Scheherazade’s mooring contract had been paid through September, according to tax records seen by CNN. Italian Sea Group will not say who paid for, or who is now paying for, those mooring costs. Since it was sequestered, Tuscan taxpayers have paid more than $15 million for the skeleton crew, some of whom are British and others Russian, which switches out several times a year, according to local press reports. A film crew that tried to approach the vessel last year was chased away by drones and water canon.
Additional costs include the security to make sure no one gets close – and that it doesn’t set sail while sequestered.
Among the other vessels that Italy is paying to keep is the Lady M, a sleek 210-foot superyacht owned by Alexei Mordashov, a Putin associate and majority shareholder in Severstal, Russia’s largest steel and mining company. Forbes puts Mordashov’s net worth at nearly $37 billion. Lady M is sequestered in Imperia, and has cost Italian taxpayers around $2 million so far, Matteo Bonjean, vice director of the port of Marina di Imperia, told Forbes.
The 126-foot superyacht Lena, owned by Gennady Timchenko, another Putin ally, is being maintained nearby.
All of the sequestered vessels have crews that maintain the yachts, paid for by the Italian government. Other costs include the use of air conditioning to prevent mold from growing inside.